Follow us on

Athens Sports Leader Online

recent on-air advertisers

Now Playing

Athens Sports Leader Online
Athens Sports Leader ...

UGA Sports

Posted: 6:37 p.m. Wednesday, Feb. 20, 2013

UGA's McGarity, others concerned about NCAA deregulation 

By Chip Towers

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution

Greg McGarity will be heading to Birmingham Thursday night with a briefcase full of concerns.

Georgia’s athletic director is among a growing number of college administrators who have reservations about the NCAA’s newly-adopted deregulation legislation. It’s just not the unlimited texting and other forms of recruiting communication that has McGarity uneasy, though that garnered the majority of media attention when the Division I board of directors initially adopted the proposals one month ago in Dallas.

It’s the other limitations that were waived -- such as the number of persons that can recruit (Proposal 11-2), the amount of full-time personnel that can be devoted to recruiting (11-4) and the amount of printed and audio/visual materials that may be utilized in the course of recruiting (13-5-A) -- that troubles McGarity.

In the ultra-competitive world that is the SEC, McGarity sees expenses spiraling out of control. He and several others are expected to voice those concerns during a regular-scheduled meeting of the SEC’s athletic directors Friday in Birmingham.

“We all know in the world of competitive sports you really are trying to get every edge you can on your opponent for your program,” McGarity said. “The creativity this is going to spark is just endless.”

The Division I board of directors, which consists of presidents and/or chancellors from 18 colleges and universities across the country, on Jan. 19 voted to adopt 25 of 27 proposals aimed at reducing the size and scope of the NCAA’s infamously thick rule book. Most of the changes were aimed at eliminating bylaws considered outdated, unenforceable or obsolete in light of technological advances in communication.

The NCAA also aimed to get its nose out of other business as well. For instance, there have been bylaws that stipulated that recruits could be provided with a bagel in certain situations, but condiments such as cream cheese or peanut butter could NOT be provided.

"Everyone was in favor of some deregulation because, with a 500-page rulebook, it’s hard to stay within the boundaries," Georgia basketball coach Mark Fox said. "We're all in favor of giving them a bagel and we’re all in favor of peanut butter, so let's get rid of that rule. I think the goal was to get rid of the rules that didn't make any sense, but evidently we've changed a lot more than that."

Particularly in the area of recruiting communications. Though well-intentioned, waiving limitations on the types and kinds of communications schools can have has effectively waived gun control in some of the already well-armed conferences, such as the SEC and Big Ten.

Soon after the NCAA board passed the new proposals, McGarity called together his 15 head coaches for a brain-storming session. He asked them to come up with ways they might be able to take advantage of the rules changes. Ideas came pouring in about multi-page, four-color recruiting brochures, fathead posters of prospects and sophisticated personalized video presentations. They heard about separate recruiting coordinators for each sport and multiple employees dedicated to nothing but communicating with recruits.

With budgets for the next fiscal year being formulated in February, McGarity started to project the additional costs. A longtime executive in college athletics, alarms began to go off in his head.

“The main issue this creates in college athletics is the haves and have-nots will be further separated and that’s not good in the big picture,” said McGarity, Georgia’s athletic since the summer of 2010. “As you see now, some institutions will dedicate more resources, more personnel – all within the rules – to certain areas of an athletic department. . . . I think the unknown is what’s scary.”

Georgia is one of only 22 Division I institutions in the country that operate in the black, according to McGarity.

Georgia State represents the other end of the spectrum. The Panthers are still trying to find their footing in the sport of football, fielding their first team in 2010, and working daily to fund 18 other sports.

“We’re always worried about budget and we always need to balance our budget,” said Cheryl Levick, Georgia State’s athletic director. “When we looked at these proposals, we knew we would stay within our budget even if they pass. We don’t have unlimited funds to add on a lot of staff.”

The good news for Levick and McGarity is these new rules are currently written in pencil. Though scheduled to go into effect in July and August of this summer, the adopted legislation was instituted under a 60-day “override period” that expires on March 20th. That means that if at least 75 of the 300-plus Division I institutions submit override votes against any of the proposals between now and then, those rules will be rescinded.

“I believe that Georgia State will support an override of a couple of the proposals,” Levick said. “We’ve already submitted an override for 11-4 (the number of coaches that can recruit). But we’ll also submit an override on 13-3 (unlimited communication with prospects, including texts and phone calls). We feel 13-3 really comes down to a student-athlete welfare issue. We’re just bugging the athletes too much. And a coach work-life balance issue, in terms of there being enough off-time for our coaches.”

Tennessee, Ohio State and Georgia Southern are among schools on record stating they will vote to override one or more of the proposals. McGarity wasn't ready to say what Georgia will do just yet.

“I’ve talked to three or four other athletic directors and we’re all thinking on the same lines in terms of concerns for allowable recruiters and the printed materials,” McGarity said. “I think everybody’s really concerned about how much that’s going to add to expenses.”

In the meantime, the predicted arms races in the SEC have already begun. Alabama, the two-time defending national football champions, earlier this week hired former Clemson defensive coordinator Kevin Steele as “director of player personnel.” Never mind that they already had somebody in that position, who will remain on staff. The Crimson Tide also has a new "director of player development."

About Chip Towers

Chip Towers covers the Georgia Bulldogs for the AJC

Send Chip Towers an email.

 
 
 

© 2013 Cox Media Group. By using this website, you accept the terms of our Visitor Agreement and Privacy Policy, and understand your options regarding Ad ChoicesAdChoices.